Showing posts with label jane bennett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jane bennett. Show all posts

Thursday, September 1, 2011

Rabbit hole detour into speculative realism

Sometimes I have those days where I wonder if I know anything, anything at all. Then there are other days where some of my wandering falls together in odd and interesting ways. The past couple of days have been a trying and emotionally turbulent roller-coaster, for a number of reasons. But amidst the turbulence, there has been one rabbit hole that has landed me in a potentially fruitful position.

Speculative realism, the vanguard of contemporary continental philosophy, in its object-oriented dispositions may help to tie together some of the disparate strands of my research I have been vainly trying to weave together using a collection of ideas that, at times, seem completely at odds. 

I have yet to really dig too deeply, but I am fruitfully seeing links between Jane Bennett's Vibrant Matter: a political ecology of things and speculative realism, in a way that makes meaningful sense to me. My problem has thus far been the nagging feeling that there is or are questions and ideas that require address before I dig into my own research. Not mere contextualizing or situating, this feeling of a constant beforehand has been plaguing my writing. Who was it that was always after the First Principles? Well, perhaps my feeling is something like that, with an added sense that I am anthropologist so do I have a business messing about in philosophy? Or perhaps the question is: how can I not do the due-diligence of exploring where the research takes me in philosophy considering my bread-and-butter is the real, the actual, the lived and the practiced? What is more apt than lived life, practiced ritual, or the sensuality of sense of both humans and things, inanimate and animate, technical, vegetable, mineral, and so on, for dipping a toe into the speculative realism pond?

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

New Feminist Materialisms

What seems to be an emerging trend in STS and remotely perhaps in anthropology, is a move towards New Feminist Materialisms. With recent publications from Jane Bennett, Vibrant Matter: a political ecology of things, an edited collection from Diana Coole and Samantha Frost: New Materialisms: Ontology, Agency, and Politics, Karen Barad's 2007, Meeting the Universe Halfway, Whatmore and Braun's, Political Matters: Technoscience, Democracy, and Public Life, and what looks to be an interesting addition by William Connolly entitled, A World of Becoming, and no doubt many other books and articles (I'm thinking of Latour and Haraway specifically), New Materialism is poised to encourage a serious rethinking of the relationship between humans and nonhumans beyond or building out from what we have seen before.

It is without doubt reframing the way I'm writing my dissertation, seeing as I consider very seriously the relationship between people and things (machines) in the concept or ritual/worship practice. So far this rethinking has led me to consider aspects (and possibilities and politics of) material agency but I have been struggling with the inherent dilemma of anthropomorphism even in the attempt to decenter the human in this story. It has been exceedingly rewarding however to read and write through some of these perspectives as they just begin to gain momentum. My hope is that my work will contribute a little something to the process.   

ShareThis